The New York Estate Tax Cliff & Your Brooklyn Brownstone

**New York imposes its own estate tax, separate from the federal one, on estates above a state exemption amount. Its defining feature is the “cliff”: if your taxable estate exceeds the exemption by more than 5%, you lose the exemption entirely and the whole estate is taxed — not just the excess. For Brooklyn families whose brownstones have appreciated into seven figures, this cliff is the central estate-tax danger. Exemption and exclusion figures change annually — verify the current-year number before relying on it.**

How the New York estate tax works

If a New York resident dies with a taxable estate above the state exemption, the estate files a New York estate tax return and pays a graduated tax. A Brooklyn estate’s value includes the full date-of-death value of the home — and that is where appreciated townhouses create exposure.

Definition — Gross estate: The total date-of-death value of everything you own or control, including real property, accounts, retirement assets, and life insurance you own.

Definition — Taxable estate: The gross estate minus deductions (debts, the unlimited marital deduction, charitable gifts) — the figure measured against the exemption.

The New York “cliff” and the 105% rule

This is the rule that surprises people:

• If your taxable estate is at or below the NY exemption, you owe no NY estate tax.
• If it exceeds the exemption by 5% or less, only the excess is taxed.
• If it exceeds the exemption by more than 5%, the exemption phases out completely and the entire estate is taxed from the first dollar.

Worked Brooklyn example. Suppose the exemption is roughly $7 million (verify the current figure). A Cobble Hill estate at exactly the exemption owes nothing. But a family whose Brooklyn Heights brownstone pushes the estate to about 105% of the exemption falls off the cliff — and tax applies to the full estate, costing hundreds of thousands of dollars that disciplined planning could have avoided. Crossing the cliff by a small margin can cost more in tax than the amount by which you exceeded it.

Federal vs. New York estate tax

Feature	Federal	New York
Separate exemption?	Yes (much higher)	Yes (lower)
Cliff / phase-out?	No	Yes (105% rule)
Portability between spouses?	Yes	No
Gift tax?	Yes	No (but 3-year add-back)
Verify current figures	Annually	Annually

Many Brooklyn estates owe no federal tax yet still face New York tax — because the state exemption is far lower.

No NY inheritance or gift tax — but a 3-year add-back

New York has no inheritance tax (a tax on the person receiving) and no separate gift tax. However, watch the three-year gift add-back: taxable gifts made within three years of death are pulled back into the New York gross estate. Deathbed gifting to dodge the cliff generally does not work in the final three years.

Portability — and why New York lacks it

Definition — Portability: A federal rule letting a surviving spouse use the deceased spouse’s unused exemption. New York has no portability.

Because New York offers no portability, a married Brooklyn couple cannot simply rely on the survivor inheriting everything. To use both spouses’ NY exemptions, they typically need a credit-shelter (bypass) trust so the first spouse’s exemption is not wasted.

Strategies to reduce the cliff exposure

• Credit-shelter / bypass trusts — capture both spouses’ NY exemptions.
• Lifetime gifting — outside the three-year window, to lower the taxable estate.
• Irrevocable life insurance trusts (ILITs) — keep policy proceeds out of the gross estate.
• Charitable gifts and bequests — reduce the taxable estate and can bring an estate back under the cliff.
• Coordinated trust planning — often the cleanest path for an appreciated brownstone.

Frequently asked questions

Does Brooklyn have its own estate tax? No — there is no city or county estate tax. Brooklyn estates face the New York State estate tax and possibly the federal one.

Will my heirs pay tax when they sell my appreciated home? Inherited property generally gets a stepped-up basis to date-of-death value, largely eliminating capital-gains tax on past appreciation — a separate, favorable rule from the estate tax.

What is the current New York estate tax exemption? It is indexed and changes each year. Always confirm the current figure rather than relying on a past number.

Can a trust avoid the NY estate tax? A revocable trust cannot, but credit-shelter trusts and ILITs can reduce or eliminate it. See trusts.

---

Tax figures change annually — confirm current-year exemptions before acting. Worried your brownstone puts you near the cliff? Book a 30-minute consultation with Russel Morgan →